Home › Guides › Etsy vs Payhip vs Gumroad for digital products
Etsy vs Payhip vs Gumroad for digital products
Fees on a $10 sale
US seller, one digital file, standard rates. Card processing for Payhip and Gumroad direct sales uses Stripe's common US rate of 2.9% + $0.30, which varies by country and card.
| Platform | What you pay | Fees | You keep |
|---|---|---|---|
| Etsy | 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 + $0.20 listing | $1.40 | $8.60 |
| Payhip Free | 5% + card processing | $1.09 | $8.91 |
| Payhip Plus ($29 a month) | 2% + card processing | $0.79 | $9.21 |
| Gumroad, direct sale | 10% + $0.50 + card processing | $2.09 | $7.91 |
| Gumroad, Discover sale | 30%, processing included | $3.00 | $7.00 |
Etsy's figure leaves out Offsite Ads, which add 15% to orders that came from Etsy's own ads. Payhip Plus also costs $29 a month, so it only pays off once your sales are high enough.
Who brings the buyers
- Etsy is a marketplace: people search it every day for printables, planners and templates, so listings can sell without your own audience.
- Payhip is your own shop. It brings almost no traffic, so you send buyers from TikTok, Pinterest, email or your website.
- Gumroad works like Payhip for your own buyers, plus a Discover marketplace that charges 30% on sales it sends you.
Who handles VAT and sales tax
- Etsy collects VAT or sales tax from buyers where the law requires and pays it for you.
- Payhip collects and pays EU and UK VAT for you. Check its tax settings for which other countries it now covers.
- Gumroad has acted as merchant of record since January 2025, handling sales tax, VAT and GST worldwide.
Which one should you use?
Most sellers do best with more than one. Keep Etsy for buyers who find you through search, and use Payhip or Gumroad for people who already follow you, where you keep more and get their email address.
Start with Etsy if you have no audience yet. Add your own shop once social media or a website starts sending you visitors.
Whichever you choose, price from what you keep, not the headline price. The free Etsy fee calculator shows what's left after Etsy's fees.
Questions sellers ask
Is Payhip cheaper than Etsy?
On fees, usually yes: on a $10 US sale you keep about $8.91 on Payhip Free against $8.60 on Etsy. But Payhip doesn't bring buyers, so the cheaper fee only helps if you have your own traffic.
Does Gumroad charge card processing on top of 10%?
On direct sales, Gumroad's help centre says card processing and PayPal fees come on top of the 10% + $0.50. Sales through Gumroad Discover cost 30% with processing included.
Can I sell the same digital product on Etsy and Payhip?
Yes. Many sellers list on Etsy for discovery and sell from their own site through Payhip or Gumroad. Keep the price the same in both places so neither group of buyers feels short-changed.
Updated 18 November 2026. Etsy's published rates as of 9 November 2026; check Etsy's Fees and Payments Policy for the latest. Estimates, not accounting or tax advice. Digital Seller Studio is not affiliated with Etsy, Inc.